When you are buying vegan boots online, the most reassuring thing is not a brand’s own marketing, it is what people who actually wear the boots have to say, especially once the newness has worn off and daily life has tested them. So rather than tell you how good New Orchard boots are, we will let our customers do it, grouped by the things that matter most when you are deciding whether to buy. For context, New Orchard is a Swiss brand: designed in Zurich, handcrafted in Italy’s Marche region, PETA-Approved Vegan and 100% vegan since day one. Every quote below is a real customer review.
Comfort that genuinely surprises people
The single most common reaction is disbelief at how comfortable ethical footwear can be. “I love my new vegan shoes!! Never thought an ethical shoe would be as comfortable. Super easy to wear, perfect fit, love how soft they are,” writes Marili. Laura describes hers as “cosy, warm and super soft,” and more than one customer notes how light they feel on the foot. For anyone who expects “vegan” to mean “stiff” or “cheap-feeling,” it is the comfort that changes their mind first.
The moment the box arrives
A lot of the warmest feedback lands the day the parcel does. “I just got them, and they are extremely beautiful… I’m super happy to have found you,” wrote Maria José P. “I just received the parcel today and I love the boots already!” said Alexandra M., while Viviana H. kept it simple: “I just received my boots and they are amazing!” For Asiye P. it was the start of something: “Today my shoes came, I love them… I’m so happy I found you, I’m sure I will buy more.” First impressions are not everything, but they set the tone, and here they are overwhelmingly happy ones.
Warm in winter, and worn all year round
New Orchard boots are built for real cold, but customers reach for them well beyond deep winter. “When autumn started, I jumped into my New Orchard boots and couldn’t stop wearing them! So warm, comfortable, easy to put on, easy to clean,” says Anna. Jael, writing from Switzerland, is even more emphatic: “the best winter shoes ever… they keep the feet warm but not sweaty and have good grip… so much better than UGGs.” That combination, warm but breathable, comes up again and again.
They keep their shape, season after season
This is where quality quietly proves itself. “It’s my second season and they still look like new, perfect shape and colour, even though I wear them basically every day,” writes Maria. Monika goes further still: “after nearly two years together, they’ve kept their shape and stayed stylish – I practically live in them year-round.” Boots that still look new after a season or two of daily wear are the clearest sign of a brand doing things properly.
Customers who come back for more
Perhaps the strongest signal of all is that people buy again, and buy for others. Krystina, from Switzerland, shares: “I already have 2 pairs and just ordered a third.” Katarina, delighted with the quality, mentions ordering two more pairs for her daughters. Repeat purchases, especially gifts, are the kind of vote of confidence no advertisement can manufacture.
Looked after, start to finish
Several customers single out the service as much as the shoes. “You have shown a 10/10 customer service, quick response, following up, so helpful, and I love that you have vegan things,” wrote Maria B. Inès S., after a smooth exchange, said simply: “I’m really happy about all the products, the quality and the design.” For a small independent brand, that kind of care is part of what keeps people coming back.
Vegan, and more comfortable than leather
For customers coming from animal leather, the comparison often surprises them. “I really love the vegan long boots, they’re so soft and much more comfortable than animal leather,” writes Rachel. It is a recurring theme: people expecting to compromise on comfort for their ethics find they do not have to.
Values that run deeper than the product
For many, the real value is in how the boots make them feel about their choice. “Thank you for these animal cruelty-free shoes, they make me feel good,” writes Patrycja, and Giulia sums up the sentiment beautifully: “the real value to me lies in knowing I’m wearing a product that respects our planet.” The brand’s animal-welfare commitment is a big part of why customers choose it in the first place. “I love your mission to support pet adoption; as an animal rights activist, I am vegan and I was looking for a good quality alternative,” wrote Mirca S. Emy J. put it just as warmly: “Thank you for a vegan company that also donates some of the proceeds to support pet adoption. LOVE that!” And Mireille Z. thanked the team “especially for your commitment to reducing animal suffering and protecting the environment.” With 10% of the order value (excluding shipping) from every green product going to animal charities, that feeling is backed by something concrete.
An honest word on fit
The response is overwhelmingly positive, but fit is personal, and the right size matters for comfort. Always check the size guide before ordering, and message the team if you are unsure or between sizes, getting the fit right first time is the surest way to join the customers above.
Light, easy, and loved for everyday
Beyond warmth and durability, a theme that runs through the reviews is how effortless the boots are to live with. Ewelina calls them “wonderful shoes, very warm and soft,” adding she is “confident I will wear them for many seasons to come.” Ela praises them as “warm, soft and light, refined in every detail.” Carol, writing from Switzerland, says they “remain in perfect quality even after wearing them many times.” And Marta loves her short boots for being “so cozy,” with a “big plus for supporting the animal shelters.” Light, warm, easy to care for, the same words come up over and over.
Customers across Europe, and the quality speaks every language
What is striking is how consistent the feedback is across countries. The reviews come from customers in Switzerland, Germany, Italy, Poland and beyond, writing in different languages but describing the same things: comfort, warmth, lasting quality and a clear conscience. Katarina, writing in German, calls them “especially beautiful shoes, outstanding quality, elegant, light and comfortable, and you know you’re doing something good, without having to go without.” Giulia, from Italy, values “wearing a product that respects our planet.” When customers in very different places independently praise the same qualities, that consistency is itself a kind of proof.
Why you can trust these reviews
It is worth noting these are real customer reviews, several accompanied by the customers’ own photos, and many from repeat buyers who have come back for a second or third pair. That matters: a one-off five-star rating is easy to dismiss, but a pattern of people buying again, gifting pairs to family, and reporting back after two years of wear is the kind of feedback that cannot be manufactured. It is the honest verdict of people who spent their own money and kept wearing the result.
See what the reviews are about, explore our vegan Classic boots.
