Skip to content

Is Vegan Leather Plastic? Let's Talk About It.

It is one of the most common questions about vegan footwear, and a completely fair one: if it is not animal leather, is it simply plastic? It is a question that deserves an honest answer rather than a defensive one, and the honest answer is “it depends.” The gap between one vegan leather and another is enormous, and that gap is where the real story lives.

“Vegan leather” is an umbrella term, not one material

The first thing to clear up is that “vegan leather” does not describe a single substance. It is a category that spans a huge range of quality and impact. At the cheapest end sit PVC-based coatings, which are genuinely plastic-heavy and often made with harsh chemistry. Further along are polyurethane (PU) microfibres, which can be engineered to be far more refined, breathable and durable. And at the newest end are bio-based materials made from plant waste, which can reduce the synthetic content, depending on their composition. Lumping all of these together as “just plastic” is like calling every car “just metal”, technically touching the truth while missing everything that matters.

What New Orchard actually uses

New Orchard’s uppers are an engineered vegan microfibre, which matters in two ways. First, it is engineered for performance, soft, breathable and durable, not the stiff plastic people picture. Second, it is made with recycled content, recycled polyamide or polyester blended with polyurethane, the exact share varying by model, so part of the material is given a second life rather than produced entirely from virgin resources. On top of that, the boots use solvent-free material technologies and water-based adhesives where applicable, rather than the harsh solvents (such as DMF) common in cheaper synthetic leathers.

The banana-waste component

Inside New Orchard boots, material derived from banana plant waste is used not only in the removable insoles but also in the internal structural construction of the boot. These components are hidden from view, but they play an important role in how the boot is built.

It is not a marketing gimmick or a token gesture, it is a real step toward reducing the purely synthetic content and using a by-product that would otherwise go to waste. It is the kind of detail that separates a thoughtful product from a careless one.

The honest part

We are not going to pretend the boots are 100% plant-based. They are partly synthetic, like essentially all high-performance footwear, vegan or not, and including plenty of leather boots, which use synthetic soles, linings, glues and finishes. What we can say honestly is that New Orchard boots avoid animal materials entirely, use recycled content and a plant-waste-derived component where possible, and are made without the harshest chemistry. For a boot that needs to be warm, water-resistant and last for years, that is a meaningful and honest middle ground, not a compromise hidden behind a slogan.

Why the comparison with animal leather still favours vegan

It is worth remembering what “natural” animal leather actually involves: raising animals, then preserving hide through chemically intensive tanning that typically relies on chromium and is heavy on water and energy. “Natural” does not mean low-impact. A considered synthetic avoids the slaughter entirely and sidesteps the worst of the tanning chemistry.

So, is it plastic?

Part synthetic, yes. “Just plastic”, no. New Orchard’s upper is an engineered vegan microfibre made with recycled content, with banana-waste-derived materials used in the insoles and internal construction; the boot is built responsibly and made to last, with none of the animal welfare cost and none of the heavy tanning chemistry of leather. That is a very different thing from the low-grade plastic the question usually imagines.

What to look for on a label

If you want to judge a vegan leather for yourself, the label and product description tell you a lot. Look for the specific material named – “recycled microfibre” or “recycled polyester” is more informative and more responsible than a vague “man-made upper.” Look for mentions of solvent-free production, which signals cleaner chemistry. Look for an OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 reference, which confirms the material was tested for harmful substances. And look for honesty: a brand that explains its mix of recycled and synthetic content in the upper, and is specific about plant-based parts such as a banana-fibre footbed, as New Orchard does, is far more trustworthy than one that hides behind a single buzzword.

A quick FAQ on vegan leather

Is recycled microfibre breathable? Good-quality microfibre is engineered to breathe far better than old PVC, which is why New Orchard customers describe the boots as warm “but not sweaty.”

Is it waterproof? It is water-resistant, with a stated protection against rain and snow for up to around 2.5 hours, and refreshing it with a vegan water-repellent spray about once a month keeps that protection up. Like most footwear, it is not built for full submersion.

Does it contain any natural material? Yes – New Orchard’s winter footbed and internal core use a banana-fibre material made from banana plant waste, alongside the engineered microfibre upper.

Is it better for the planet than leather? For most measures, a considered recycled synthetic avoids the slaughter and the heavy tanning chemistry of animal leather. No footwear is impact-free, but the honest comparison favours the vegan option.

Animal leather comes with the environmental impact of livestock farming, including greenhouse gas emissions, as well as water consumption and the chemical-intensive tanning process. Well-made vegan alternatives, especially those using recycled materials, can significantly reduce some of these impacts without harming animals. No footwear is impact-free, but there are compelling environmental and ethical reasons to choose vegan.

Explore boots made the considered way, shop New Orchard.

Cart

By purchasing any of our green product, you spend 10% on pets.
Sky blue vegan dog hoodie made from recycled materials with hood and snap closure. - The New Orchard - Sky Blue / 2XS
Dog Hoodie Blue CHF 59.00
Sky Blue, 2XS
CHF 59.00

Select options